Birds are categorically different from the other three classes in that
the Torah offers no identifying features to distinguish the kosher from
the non-kosher species. The Torah simply provides a listing of those birds
that are not kosher. An even score of species are listed 3
and after several of them "and its species" is stated, for a total of 24
non-kosher species. 4
By inference, all of the other, vast number of bird species, are kosher. 5
Thus, for Moshe Rabbenu, or any expert ornithologist who is able to correctly
identify the 24 listed species, things are relatively straightforward -
all other birds are kosher. However, today when these can no longer be
accurately identified, things are quite a bit more complicated. 6
"In order to fully explain the identification of kosher birds would take
a small booklet of its own" (Minchat Chinuch, mitzvah 157). And Chatam
Sofer, Rabbi Yonatan Eibschitz, and others wrote several. What will be
presented here is, by necessity, only a brief summary of the main ideas,
with a focus on those relevant to the question of turkey.
KASHRUT OF BIRDS - THE RABBINIC STORY:
KASHRUT OF BIRDS - THE NEED FOR A MESORAH:
MESORAHS: TRANSMITTING, MAKING, APPLYING, AND AMENDING:
KASHRUT OF THE TURKEY
Comments to webmaster@kashrut.com
© Copyright 2024 Scharf Associates |
|